Stellungnahme zum Leistungsschutzrecht für Presseverleger in Österreich

Nikolaus Forgó hat eine Stellungnahme zum gerade in Begutachtung befindlichen Vorschlag einer Novelle des österreichischen Urheberrechtsgesetzes abgegeben. Mit dieser soll unter anderem ein Leistungsschutzrecht für Presseverleger eingeführt werden. Der Vorschlag ist sehr umstritten und kann weitreichende Auswirkungen auf den Medienmarkt in Österreich haben. Forgó empfiehlt dringend, von einer Einführung des Leistungsschutzrechts abzusehen. Die Stellungnahme ist hier verfügbar: Stellungnahme Forgó

Der nun offizielle Ministerialentwurf ist wortidentisch mit einer „informellen“,  geleakten Version aus dem Juni 2014. Zu dieser erschien schon 2014 in der Zeitschrift für Informationsrecht ein Beitrag Forgós, der hier gelesen werden kann.

Mapping – Extraordinary General Assembly

MAPPING has its first General Assembly Meeting today. Mapping is an FP-7 project dealing with the future of the internet. Today’s morning session – dealing with privacy issues – is chaired by the project’s coordinator, Prof. Joe Cannataci.

First speaker is Dr. Jens Lütcke from sofort SOFORT.AG. Sofort is a startup offering payment services for internet. Lütcke identifies four key for development of e-commerce in Europe: Search, Platforms, Social Services and Payment Services. 3 out of those 4 are dominated by US-companies (Google, Amazon, Facebook), only payment services is still a market open for  European industry leader. ‚People who see what you pay for are those who know what you are really interested in as you are even willing to pay for it‘, he argues. It’s important to develop a European position in this market for thisi reason, however, US-companies try to enter the market aggressively.

Businesses need common standards, as needing to speak to 28 different authorities is an obstacle for pan-European players. The market doesn’t work on a national level.  Lack of technical expertise within data protection authorities is also an issue as lack of knowledge causes lack of confidence. Mistrust in technology is a permanent issue. Data protection and data security law can – in Lütcke’s judgement – be missused to keep new players out of the market – in particular in the payment industry.

His main conludions are: Rules need to be enforced and enforceable . we have a lot of rules, but many of them are not enforced. The market today is dominated by players not necessarily following the rules. Regulators need better technical understanding. Risk analysis should be standard procedure of regulators. Finally, a global view needs to be found – Europe is not an island.